Do I Have to Use My Insurance Company's Contractor After a Fire?

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Do I Have to Use My Insurance Company's Contractor After a Fire?

Within hours of a fire, you may hear from a restoration company your insurer recommended, sometimes before you have even talked to an adjuster. Many homeowners assume they have to use that company. In most cases, you do not. You choose who repairs your home. But the choice has consequences for how your claim is valued and who is responsible if the work is poor.

Insurer "preferred" contractors and how they work

Many insurers run preferred vendor or managed repair programs. Contractors in the program agree to the insurer's pricing guidelines, often at a discount, and to its documentation rules. In return they get a steady stream of jobs. Their estimate often becomes the insurer's valuation of the repair.

That arrangement can be convenient: fast scheduling, direct billing and less paperwork for you. But the contractor has two customers, you and the insurer, and the insurer sends the repeat business.

Can the insurer make you use its contractor?

Generally no. Your policy obligates the insurer to pay for covered damage, not to choose who does the work. Some states say so explicitly. California's claim regulations prohibit an insurer from requiring that property be repaired by a specific individual or company. An insurer may only recommend a contractor if you ask for a referral or it tells you in writing that you have the right to choose your own. And if you use the contractor it recommended, the insurer must make sure the property is restored to at least its pre-loss condition at no additional cost to you.

For wildfire smoke claims, California's Smoke Damage Recovery Act, effective January 1, 2027, also preserves your right to choose your restoration contractor.

The catch: whose price sets the claim?

If you choose your own contractor and its price is higher than the preferred vendor's, the insurer may only want to pay the lower number. That is where disputes start. What settles them is the reasonable cost, in your local market, to restore your home to its pre-loss condition. California regulations, for example, require insurers to take reasonable steps to make sure the repair costs they use reflect the local market.

If your contractor's estimate is higher, ask both to write line-item estimates in the same format so the differences are visible. See how to counter a lowball fire offer.

Overhead and profit when you hire a general contractor

Fire repairs usually involve many trades: demolition, framing, drywall, electrical, HVAC, painting, flooring. When a job needs a general contractor to coordinate them, the contractor charges overhead and profit, often called O&P. A common figure is "10 and 10," meaning 10% overhead and 10% profit, about 20% on top of the trade costs.

Some adjusters apply a "three-trade rule" and leave O&P out unless three or more trades are involved. That rule is a rule of thumb. It is not written in the standard policy. In Pennsylvania, the court in Gilderman v. State Farm held that O&P is owed, including in the actual cash value payment, when a general contractor is reasonably likely to be needed. Fire claims almost always meet that test. Check that the insurer's estimate includes O&P when your contractor's does. See how fire claims are calculated.

Depreciation on labor

Some insurers depreciate labor in an actual cash value estimate. In California, insurers may not depreciate the labor to repair, rebuild or replace under fire policies. Elsewhere the rule varies, so ask the insurer to show labor and materials separately and explain any depreciation in writing. See recoverable depreciation after a fire.

What to check before signing with any restoration company

  • Licensing and insurance: confirm the company holds the required contractor license and carries liability and workers' compensation insurance.
  • Fire and smoke experience: ask whether its technicians are trained to the IICRC fire and smoke restoration standard.
  • Scope: the contract should describe the work, not just say "restore property."
  • Pricing: how will it bill? Many use Xactimate pricing.
  • Payment terms: watch for clauses that let the company collect directly from your insurer, sometimes called a direction to pay or assignment of benefits. These can give the contractor control over part of your claim.
  • Cancellation: how can you end the contract, and what do you owe if you do?
  • Contents: if the company packs out your belongings, ask for a detailed inventory with photos.

What your mortgage company may ask about your contractor

If you have a mortgage, dwelling payments usually go through your lender. Servicers following Fannie Mae rules may ask for your contractor's information, a statement that you intend to repair, and lien waivers as work is paid. Larger claims are often released in stages after inspections. Rules depend on the loan type. A contractor who is used to this paperwork will get paid faster, and so will your rebuild. See mortgage company holding the insurance check.

Emergency work vs. rebuild

It is common to use one company for emergency mitigation (board-up, water extraction, smoke cleanup) and a different contractor for the rebuild. Signing with a company for emergency work does not obligate you to let it rebuild your home. Read the emergency contract carefully for language that does. See the fire damage restoration process.

If you use the insurer's contractor and the work is poor

Report problems in writing to both the contractor and the insurer, with photos. If the insurer recommended the contractor, it may share responsibility for getting the work done right, and in California it must ensure pre-loss condition. Do not sign a certificate of completion until the work is actually finished and acceptable.

Common questions

Can I fire the restoration company my insurer sent?

Usually yes, subject to the contract you signed. Check the cancellation terms and pay for work already done.

Will insurance pay my own contractor's price?

It pays the reasonable cost to restore the home in your local market. If your contractor's price is higher, compare line-item estimates to show why.

Should I sign an assignment of benefits with a contractor?

Be careful. It can give the contractor control over part of your claim. Read it closely and ask questions before signing.

Is a general contractor's overhead and profit covered?

Often yes, when a general contractor is reasonably likely to be needed. Pennsylvania courts have held it is owed in that situation, even in the actual cash value payment.

Will my lender want my contractor's details?

Often. Servicers following Fannie Mae rules may ask for contractor information, your intent to repair and lien waivers before releasing funds.

Help choosing and managing contractors on a fire claim

ClaimWarriors works with your chosen contractor to document the full scope and price of repairs and negotiate them with the insurer. See how we handle fire damage claims, or contact us for a claim review.

This article is general information about property insurance claims, not legal advice. Contractor rules vary by state. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050