Public Adjuster vs Attorney for a Fire Claim: Who Does What

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Public Adjuster vs Attorney for a Fire Claim: Who Does What

After a fire, people often hear two kinds of advice: "get a public adjuster" and "get a lawyer." Both can help, but they do different jobs. Choosing the right one depends on what is actually wrong with your claim. This guide compares a public adjuster vs an attorney for fire claims.

What a public adjuster does

A public adjuster is licensed by your state's insurance department to represent policyholders in presenting and negotiating insurance claims. On a fire claim, a public adjuster typically:

  • Reviews the policy for every coverage that applies.
  • Documents fire, smoke and water damage throughout the property.
  • Writes a line-item repair or rebuild estimate.
  • Builds and prices the contents inventory.
  • Tracks living expenses, deadlines and depreciation holdbacks.
  • Negotiates the amount of the claim with the insurer, and can serve or coordinate in appraisal.

Public adjusters are usually paid a percentage of the claim payments they help recover. See public adjuster fees on fire claims.

What a public adjuster cannot do

A public adjuster cannot give legal advice, file a lawsuit or represent you in court. If the dispute turns on legal questions, such as whether a policy exclusion applies, whether you breached the policy or whether the insurer acted in bad faith, you need an attorney.

What an insurance attorney does

A policyholder attorney advises on your legal rights, interprets disputed policy language, represents you at an examination under oath, sends demand letters, files suit and handles litigation, including bad faith claims. Many work on contingency in property cases, though fee arrangements vary.

How the fees compare

Both are often paid a percentage of what they recover, so compare them on the money each one is likely to add. Some states cap public adjuster fees, for example New York at 12.5% and Florida at 20% (10% after emergencies). Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan and Mississippi cap at 10%. Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Colorado, Connecticut, Indiana, Minnesota, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oregon and Washington have no statutory percentage cap, according to industry trackers, though fees may need to be reasonable. California has no cap either; a 2025 cap bill was not enacted. Attorney fees vary, and in some states a bad faith win can shift attorney fees to the insurer.

Bad faith laws only an attorney can use

Several states give policyholders extra remedies when an insurer acts unreasonably. Colorado lets a policyholder recover twice the covered benefit plus attorney fees for an unreasonable delay or denial. Pennsylvania's bad faith statute allows interest, punitive damages, court costs and attorney fees. Washington's Insurance Fair Conduct Act allows up to three times actual damages plus fees, after 20 days' notice. New Jersey applies a common law test that asks whether the insurer had a fairly debatable reason to deny. These are lawsuits, so a public adjuster can document the facts but an attorney has to bring the claim. See bad faith insurance claims.

When a public adjuster is the right fit

  • The insurer accepts the fire is covered, but the numbers are too low.
  • The smoke damage scope, contents inventory or code upgrades are incomplete.
  • You need help preparing the proof of loss, supplements or recoverable depreciation requests.
  • The claim is slow or confusing, but not in a coverage fight.

When you need an attorney

When to use both

Many serious fire claims involve both. A typical pattern: the public adjuster documents and values the loss, while an attorney handles a coverage question or the EUO. If the case goes to litigation, the adjuster's estimate and inventory often become key evidence. The two roles work well together when they communicate and when fee arrangements are clear about who is paid on what.

Appraisal: a middle path

If the only dispute is the amount of the loss, many policies allow appraisal. Under the standard form, either side can demand it in writing, each side picks an appraiser within 20 days, and the two appraisers choose an umpire. Appraisal does not decide coverage questions, such as whether an exclusion applies, so a dispute that mixes amount and coverage may need both an appraiser and an attorney. See the appraisal clause.

Questions to ask either one

  • Are you licensed in my state? (Check the state insurance department or state bar.)
  • How many fire claims have you handled, and what were the results?
  • How are you paid, and on which money?
  • Who will work on my file day to day?
  • What is your plan for my claim, and what will you need from me?

Cancelling a public adjuster contract

Many states give you a short window to cancel a public adjuster contract after signing. In California it is 5 days, and public adjusters there cannot solicit you until 7 days after a catastrophic disaster ends. Check your state's rules and read the cancellation section before you sign.

A note on timing

Bringing in help early is easier than fixing a claim later. Before you sign a proof of loss with the insurer's number, give a sworn statement or accept a "final" payment, get a review. See should you hire a public adjuster after a house fire.

Common questions

Can a public adjuster sue my insurance company?

No. Only an attorney can file a lawsuit on your behalf. A public adjuster handles the documentation and negotiation of the claim.

Is it worth hiring both a public adjuster and an attorney?

On large or disputed claims, sometimes. The adjuster prices the loss and the attorney handles coverage disputes and litigation. Confirm how fees will work together.

Who should I call first after a fire claim denial?

If the denial alleges fraud, arson or misrepresentation, an attorney. If the dispute is about the amount, a public adjuster. See why fire claims are denied.

Can I cancel a public adjuster contract?

Usually, within a short window set by state law. California allows 5 days. Check your state's rules and the contract.

Can a public adjuster handle appraisal?

Often, yes, as your appraiser or by coordinating with one, depending on state rules. Appraisal decides the amount of loss, not coverage.

Talk to us about your fire claim

ClaimWarriors is a public adjusting firm. Our fee is a percentage of the settlement we obtain, and there is no fee if there is no recovery. We work with policyholders' attorneys when a claim needs both. See our fire claim services, or contact us for a claim review.

Fee cap information comes from industry trackers as of 2025 and may change. This article is general information, not legal advice. Licensing and fee rules vary by state. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050