Can You Change Your Insurance Adjuster? How to Ask for a New One

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Two people talking across a desk in an office

Can you change your insurance adjuster? You can't fire the insurance company's adjuster, because they work for the insurer. But you can ask the insurer to assign someone else, and a specific, documented reason gives the request a better chance, such as missed inspections, unanswered messages or clear errors in the estimate. If the insurer refuses, you can escalate to a claims manager, file a complaint with your state insurance department, or hire a public adjuster who works for you.

If you're asking this, you may be frustrated with one person on your claim. This guide explains when a change is worth requesting, how to ask in a way that works, and what other options you have.

Who the adjuster works for

The adjuster on your claim is either a staff adjuster employed by your insurer or an independent adjuster the insurer hired. Either way, the insurer decides who handles the file. No standard homeowners policy gives you the right to choose or replace the insurer's adjuster. That decision belongs to the insurer.

What you do control is who represents you. You can hire a public adjuster, who is licensed by the state to work only for policyholders. Our guide to the public adjuster vs insurance adjuster explains the difference.

Good reasons to ask for a new adjuster

Requests based on specific problems get results. Requests based on "I don't like them" are harder to justify. Strong reasons include:

  • The adjuster has not responded to written messages for weeks, past your state's reply deadline.
  • The adjuster missed or rescheduled inspections repeatedly.
  • The inspection was clearly incomplete, such as no roof access on a roof claim or no moisture readings on a water claim.
  • The estimate leaves out rooms, areas or damage you documented, and the adjuster won't explain why.
  • The adjuster misstated your policy or pressured you to accept a settlement on the spot.
  • The adjuster was rude, unprofessional or made comments that suggest bias.

State rules give you a measuring stick. States such as California, Pennsylvania and New Jersey require insurers to reply to claim communications within 10 to 15 days. Our guide on an insurance adjuster not responding lists the deadlines in several states.

How to ask for a different adjuster

1. Go above the adjuster

Call the claims line and ask for the adjuster's supervisor or the claims manager for your area. Get their name and email. Asking the adjuster directly may not help, since adjusters may not control their own assignments.

2. Put the request in writing

Send a short, factual email. Stick to dates and documents. For example:

"Claim number 12-34567. I am requesting that a different adjuster be assigned to this claim. Since the inspection on August 4, I have sent four emails, on August 12, 19 and 26 and September 3, with no reply. The estimate dated August 9 does not include the hallway or the kitchen ceiling, both shown in the photos I sent on August 5. I would like a new adjuster to reinspect the property. Please confirm in writing who will handle this claim going forward."

3. Ask for what you actually need

What you may need is a new look at the claim, which doesn't require a new person. Ask for a reinspection, a review of the estimate by a supervisor, or a written explanation of any item the insurer won't pay. Those requests are harder to refuse than a personnel change.

4. Keep it professional

Everything you write goes in the claim file. A calm, documented request makes the insurer's next steps easier to defend. An angry one gives them reasons to dig in. See what not to say to an insurance adjuster.

After a storm, the adjuster may change anyway

After a hailstorm, wildfire or hurricane, insurers may bring in independent adjusters from other states for a few weeks. When they rotate out, your file moves to someone new, sometimes more than once. If that has happened, ask the claims manager who owns the file now, whether the new adjuster has read the earlier notes and photos, and whether any promises made by the first adjuster, such as a reinspection or an advance payment, are still in place. Put the answers in an email back to them so the commitments carry over.

If the insurer says no

File a complaint with your state insurance department

Describe the specific problems and attach your emails and claim log. The department sends the complaint to the insurer, which must respond. Complaints about missed deadlines and unanswered communications are exactly what claims regulations cover. Find your department through the NAIC directory. If the adjuster holds a state license, the department's licensing division can also review their conduct.

Use the appraisal clause for price disputes

If the problem is the amount and not the person, and the insurer agrees the loss is covered, the policy's appraisal clause lets each side pick an appraiser and an umpire settle the difference. See our guide to the homeowners insurance appraisal clause.

Hire your own adjuster

A public adjuster takes over communication with the insurer, writes their own estimate and negotiates for you. It doesn't remove the insurer's adjuster from the claim, but it changes who you have to deal with. Read is a public adjuster worth it to decide if the fee makes sense.

Can you change your public adjuster?

That is a different question. A public adjuster works for you under a contract, so the contract decides how you end it. States such as Pennsylvania give you a short window after signing to cancel without penalty, and after that the contract's own terms apply. See how to fire a public adjuster or cancel the contract.

What changing adjusters won't fix

A new adjuster still applies the same policy. If the damage is excluded, a new person will reach the same answer. And a reassignment can slow the claim while the new adjuster gets up to speed. Before you ask for a change, decide whether the problem is the person, the evidence, or the policy. A better-documented claim, with your own contractor's estimate and photos, can do more than a new name on the file. Our guide to negotiating with your insurance adjuster shows how to build that file.

Common questions

Can you fire your insurance adjuster?

Not the insurer's adjuster. You can ask the insurer to reassign the claim, and you can hire and fire your own public adjuster under the terms of your contract.

Will asking for a new adjuster hurt my claim?

A polite, documented request should not. Insurers reassign files regularly. Keep the request factual and focused on the claim.

How do I complain about an insurance adjuster?

Start with the adjuster's supervisor in writing. If that doesn't work, file a complaint with your state insurance department and include your claim log and emails.

Can I request a second inspection?

Yes. Ask in writing and explain what the first inspection missed. A reinspection can be a quick way to fix an incomplete estimate.

Tired of fighting your adjuster?

ClaimWarriors works only for policyholders and handles the back and forth with your insurer. See our public adjuster services or contact us for a free claim review.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Claim handling rules vary by state. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050