Will My Homeowners Insurance Go Up if I File a Claim?

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Calculator, pen and paperwork on a desk

Will my homeowners insurance go up if I file a claim? It can. NerdWallet's 2026 analysis found that one wind or weather claim raised the median premium by about 10% nationally, and MoneyGeek found an average increase of about 16% for one claim in the past five years. The increase can show up at renewal and, according to GEICO, may stay for three to five years. How much you pay depends on your insurer's rating plan, the type and size of the claim, your claims history and your state's rules.

Rates rise for other reasons too. Premiums can rise even without a claim when insurers raise rates across a region. This guide separates the two and explains how to limit the effect of a claim.

How much rates go up after a claim

Studies of insurer rate filings give a range:

  • NerdWallet's 2026 home insurance pricing report, using Quadrant Information Services data from early 2026, found one wind or weather claim raised the median premium 10.2% nationally, with some states more than double that.
  • MoneyGeek's October 2026 analysis of Quadrant data found one claim in the past five years raised the average premium about 16%, from $3,467 to $4,019, according to Insuranceopedia.
  • Policygenius puts the average annual cost at $1,908 with no claims, $2,101 with one claim, $2,916 with three, and $4,407 with five.

The spread shows how much depends on the insurer and the state. A second or third claim can cost more than the first.

Why insurers raise rates after a claim

Insurers price policies on the likelihood of future claims. As the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance puts it, insurance company studies show a relationship between past claims and claims you report in the future. So a claim can move you into a higher-risk rating group. You may also lose a claims-free discount, which some insurers give after three to five years without a claim. That loss can look like a rate increase even when no surcharge is added.

Not every claim counts the same. Rating plans differ by insurer, and some treat weather claims, claims that paid nothing, and repeat claims of the same type differently. Ask your agent how your insurer's plan works before you file.

Rates can rise even without a claim

If your renewal jumped and you didn't file anything, the cause may be regional. Insurify reported that the average U.S. homeowner paid 12% more for insurance in 2025, and LexisNexis found the average cost per home insurance claim hit a record high that year, up almost 26% from 2024. When claims in your area get more expensive, insurers raise rates for everyone there. Ask your agent whether your increase came from a surcharge on your own policy or from a rate filing that applies to all customers.

How long a claim affects your rates

According to GEICO, claims usually affect your premium at your next renewal. GEICO notes the effect may stay on your record for three to five years. Separately, LexisNexis's C.L.U.E. database, which insurers use when you apply for a new policy, keeps up to seven years of home and auto claims, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. So a claim can follow you if you switch insurers within that window.

State rules that limit increases

Some states restrict what insurers can do after certain claims:

  • In Maryland, an insurer can't cancel or refuse to renew a homeowners policy for weather-related claims unless there were three or more in three years. Maryland's regulation presumes a claim is weather-related when snow, rain, sleet, hail, lightning, freezing or thawing caused it.
  • In Texas, according to Insuranceopedia, an insurer can't raise your premium over a weather-related claim or a claim it didn't pay, and other claims count only once you've filed two or more in three years.
  • A 2017 Rutgers and United Policyholders study found 22 states bar insurers from treating a simple inquiry about coverage as a claim.

Your state insurance department can tell you which protections apply where you live. The NAIC directory links to each one.

Does asking about coverage count as a claim?

It can. The Utah Insurance Department warns that contacting your insurer or agent about an actual loss may be treated as reporting a claim, even if nothing is paid. General questions about what your policy covers or what your deductible is are different. LexisNexis advises insurers not to report those. If you're unsure, read your policy first or ask general questions without describing a specific loss.

How to limit the impact

  1. Use insurance for losses that matter. Pay small repairs near your deductible yourself. Our guide on whether to file a homeowners claim shows the math.
  2. Fix the cause of the loss so it doesn't happen again. Repeat water claims can be a problem, and our guide to water damage coverage explains which leaks are covered.
  3. Ask about claim forgiveness. Some insurers sell an endorsement that waives the surcharge on a first claim.
  4. Raise your deductible if you plan to self-insure small losses anyway, and use the savings toward repairs.
  5. Shop at renewal. Insurers weigh claims differently, so another company may price your history better.
  6. Make sure any claim you do file is paid in full. A public adjuster can help on large losses, as our guide on whether a public adjuster is worth it explains.
  7. Check your C.L.U.E. report for errors. You can get a free copy once a year from LexisNexis and dispute mistakes.

Don't skip a claim you need

Fear of a rate increase leads some people to absorb losses they should have claimed. For a fire, a major water loss, storm damage to the roof or anyone getting hurt on your property, the payout is likely to be worth more than a few years of higher premiums. A higher premium is also better than losing coverage for a loss you never reported, because waiting can create late notice problems later. If you're worried about being dropped altogether, see can homeowners insurance drop you after a claim.

And when you do file, make it count. A claim that is underpaid still goes on your record. Our guide on how to file a homeowners insurance claim covers the steps that protect the payout.

Common questions

Do home insurance rates go up after a claim that isn't my fault?

They can. Insurers can rate weather claims too, though some states limit that. Check your state's rules and ask your insurer how it treats weather claims.

How much does homeowners insurance go up after a roof claim?

Triple-I data shows wind and hail claims have the highest frequency among homeowners losses. NerdWallet found a median increase of about 10% after one wind or weather claim, with wide differences by state.

Will a denied claim raise my rates?

It may be recorded even if nothing is paid, and some insurers consider it. Some states, like Texas, bar raising premiums over a claim the insurer didn't pay.

Can I switch insurers after filing a claim?

Yes, but the new insurer can see the claim on your C.L.U.E. report for up to seven years.

Want to get the most out of a claim?

If you're going to file, ClaimWarriors can make sure the claim pays what your policy owes. See our public adjuster services or contact us for a free claim review.

This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. Rating rules vary by insurer and state. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050