Overhead and Profit Insurance Claims: When You're Owed 10 and 10

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Construction worker in a hard hat cutting lumber on a job site

On an overhead and profit insurance claim, the question is whether your repair reasonably needs a general contractor. If it does, the insurer's estimate should include the general contractor's overhead and profit, which contractors may figure as 10% overhead plus 10% profit and called "10 and 10." If the job is a single trade, like a roofer replacing a roof, overhead and profit may not be owed on top of that trade's price.

Overhead and profit, or O&P, can be a large gap between an insurer's estimate and a contractor's bid. On a large claim it can be tens of thousands of dollars. This guide explains when it applies, how insurers handle it before and after repairs, and how to ask for it.

What overhead and profit means

Every trade line in an insurance estimate, such as drywall, flooring or painting, is priced at what that trade charges. When a job needs several trades, a general contractor schedules them, orders materials, manages permits and inspections, supervises the work and carries the insurance and warranty. The general contractor's charge for that work is overhead, plus a margin, which is profit.

Estimates may show O&P as a percentage added to the repair cost. The trial court opinion in Kurach v. Truck Insurance Exchange, a Pennsylvania case discussed below, described a 20% calculation as the insurance industry standard for estimating it. United Policyholders, a national consumer group, says 10% overhead and 10% profit is standard in Colorado and can be negotiated higher on complex projects. Your policy does not set the percentage.

When a general contractor is "reasonably likely"

Courts, such as Pennsylvania's Superior Court in Mee v. Safeco, look at whether a general contractor is reasonably likely to be needed for the repair. Pennsylvania's Superior Court put it that way in Mee v. Safeco (2006), looking at the nature of the damage and the number of trades the repair involves.

Signs that O&P belongs in the estimate:

  • Three or more trades are needed, such as demolition, drying, drywall, insulation, electrical, flooring, cabinets and painting.
  • The work has to happen in sequence, with one trade waiting on another.
  • Permits, inspections or code upgrades are required.
  • The house is not livable during the repair.
  • It is a fire, a major water loss or structural damage.

Signs it may not apply: a single trade, a small repair one contractor can handle alone, or a contents-only claim.

Overhead and profit before you repair: the ACV question

The standard form pays in two stages. First the insurer pays actual cash value, which is the repair cost minus depreciation. Then it pays the rest after you complete the repairs. Disputes can center on whether O&P belongs in that first payment.

Pennsylvania

In Gilderman v. State Farm (1994), the Superior Court held that an insurer could not automatically withhold both depreciation and a flat 20% for overhead and profit from its actual cash value payment. Mee v. Safeco later said O&P belongs in the ACV payment when a general contractor is reasonably likely to be needed, even if the homeowner does not end up using one.

That is not the end of the story. In 2020, in Kurach v. Truck Insurance Exchange, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled 4 to 3 that an insurer can withhold general contractor O&P from ACV payments when the policy clearly says so, according to a summary by the law firm Cozen O'Connor. So in Pennsylvania, the answer depends on your policy wording. Look in the loss settlement section and any endorsements for language about general contractor fees in actual cash value settlements.

Colorado

Colorado's Division of Insurance has a long-standing bulletin, B-5.1, stating that deducting contractors' overhead and profit in addition to depreciation is not consistent with the definition of actual cash value under replacement cost policies where repairs are not made. The Division considered withdrawing the bulletin in 2019 and kept it. Bulletins are the Division's interpretation, not binding law, but they carry weight in Colorado claims.

Other states

Courts elsewhere have taken different views, and some follow the Pennsylvania reasoning. An Arizona appeals court did in Tritschler v. Allstate (2006). Because the rules vary, check your policy and your state, and ask the insurer in writing to explain the legal basis if it withholds O&P.

Overhead and profit after you repair

Once repairs are done, the question gets simpler. If you hired a general contractor and paid O&P, send the invoice and ask for the replacement cost holdback, including O&P. If you managed the trades yourself, an insurer may refuse to pay O&P you did not actually pay. Keep in mind that under the standard ISO homeowners form, you must tell the insurer within 180 days after the loss if you intend to claim the additional replacement cost amount. Read more in our guide to recoverable depreciation.

How to ask for overhead and profit

  1. Count the trades. List every trade in your contractor's estimate and in the insurer's estimate.
  2. Get a letter from your general contractor explaining what coordination the job needs, how many trades, and that they will manage it.
  3. Send a written request that cites the number of trades, the complexity, and any state rule that applies.
  4. If the insurer refuses, ask for its reason in writing and the policy provision it relies on.
  5. If the dispute is only about the amount and the loss is covered, consider the appraisal clause.

For the rest of the estimate, our guide to negotiating with your insurance adjuster walks through each section line by line.

Example: a kitchen water loss

A dishwasher supply line fails and water spreads under the kitchen floor and into the finished basement below. The repair needs water mitigation, demolition, drywall, insulation, electrical work in the basement, new flooring, cabinet removal and reinstall, and painting. That is at least seven trades, and the work has to happen in order. The water damage itself is covered as an accidental discharge, as our guide to water damage coverage explains. The insurer's estimate totals $48,000 without O&P. The homeowner's general contractor writes a letter explaining the scope and sequencing. The insurer adds 10% overhead and 10% profit, about $9,600. These figures are illustrative. The real amount depends on your estimate, your policy and your state.

Common questions

Does insurance pay overhead and profit?

Yes, when a general contractor is reasonably needed for the repair. Whether it is paid before repairs depends on your policy wording and your state.

What is 10 and 10 in insurance?

It is shorthand for 10% overhead plus 10% profit added to the repair estimate for a general contractor. The percentage is a convention, not a policy term, and it can be argued up or down.

Is overhead and profit owed on a roof-only claim?

It may not be, because a roofing company is one trade. If the job also needs gutters, siding, interior repairs and permits coordinated together, the answer can change.

Can the insurer take O&P out of the ACV payment?

It depends on your state and policy. In Colorado the Division of Insurance says it should not. In Pennsylvania it can if the policy clearly says so.

Make sure your estimate is complete

ClaimWarriors writes full estimates that include overhead and profit when the job calls for it, and negotiates them with your insurer. Learn what a public adjuster does, see our public adjuster services, or request a free claim review.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Court decisions and regulator positions on overhead and profit vary by state and change over time. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050