Roof Depreciation in an Insurance Claim: ACV Roofs, Age Schedules and Holdbacks

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Roof Depreciation in an Insurance Claim: ACV Roofs, Age Schedules and Holdbacks

A 15-year-old roof is damaged by hail. The insurer agrees the roof needs replacing, then pays less than half of the estimate. The gap is roof depreciation. Whether you get that money back depends on how your policy settles roof losses, and that is often decided by an endorsement you may not know you have.

Replacement cost with a holdback

Under the standard homeowners form (ISO HO-3), a roof insured at replacement cost is paid in two steps. The insurer pays actual cash value first, which is replacement cost minus depreciation. It pays the rest, often called recoverable depreciation, after the roof is actually replaced. You must tell the insurer within 180 days after the date of loss that you intend to repair or replace. Full replacement cost applies only if the house is insured for at least 80% of its full replacement cost.

Actual cash value roof endorsements

Many insurers limit roof coverage by endorsement. ISO's HO 04 93, Actual Cash Value Loss Settlement for Windstorm or Hail Losses to Roof Surfacing, changes the settlement of roof surfacing damaged by wind or hail to actual cash value. Depreciation taken under it is not paid back when the roof is replaced. Insurers often add it at new business when the roof's age does not qualify for replacement cost. Some carriers use their own forms, including schedules that pay a percentage of the roof cost based on the roof's age.

These endorsements apply to roof surfacing as the endorsement defines it, and only to wind and hail losses. Interior damage and other parts of the house are generally settled under the policy's normal rules. Read the definition in your endorsement.

How depreciation is calculated

No standard policy sets a roof depreciation schedule. Insurers usually start from the roof's age and an expected life for the material, sometimes adjusted for condition. Those are the numbers to check.

  • Age: insurers sometimes estimate it from photos or public records. Your installation invoice, permit or home inspection report is better evidence.
  • Expected life: shingles are sold with different rated lives, and a premium architectural shingle should not be depreciated like a basic three-tab.
  • Condition: a well-kept roof should not carry the same depreciation as a neglected one.
  • Labor: rules on depreciating labor vary by state and by policy. Ask the insurer to show whether labor was depreciated and on what basis.

Example: a 15-year-old roof

Illustrative numbers: a hail-damaged roof costs $20,000 to replace. The roof is 15 years old and the insurer assumes a 25-year life, so it depreciates 60%, or $12,000.

  • On a replacement cost policy, the first payment is $20,000 minus $12,000 minus a $1,500 deductible, or $6,500. After the new roof is installed, the insurer releases the $12,000, for a total of $18,500.
  • With an actual cash value roof endorsement, the payment stops at $6,500.
  • If the homeowner shows the roof was installed 10 years ago with a 30-year shingle, depreciation drops to about 33%, or $6,667, and the actual cash value payment rises to about $11,833.

What to ask the adjuster

  • What age did you use for the roof, and where did that number come from?
  • What expected life did you use for this shingle?
  • Is the depreciation recoverable, and which part of the policy says so?
  • Was depreciation applied to labor, tear-off or disposal?
  • Does the roof endorsement reach the gutters, vents and flashing, or only the shingles?

Get the answers in writing. A depreciation line with no explanation is the easiest part of a roof estimate to challenge.

Getting the recoverable depreciation

  1. Confirm in writing that the roof is on replacement cost and how much is being held back.
  2. Send notice of intent to replace within 180 days after the loss, even if the work comes later.
  3. Replace the roof and send the final invoice, proof of payment and photos.
  4. Include anything found during tear-off, such as damaged decking. See claim supplements.

For the same rules in fire claims, see recoverable depreciation after a fire and actual cash value vs replacement cost.

Repair or replace changes the depreciation

A repair of a few squares carries little depreciation in dollars, and a full replacement carries a lot. If the insurer agrees to replace, check the depreciation. If it insists on a repair, check whether a repair can match. See roof repair vs replacement.

Before the next storm

  • Check your declarations page for roof endorsements and a separate wind or hail deductible. See how to read a declarations page.
  • Keep the invoice and permit for your current roof.
  • Ask your agent what replacement cost coverage on the roof would cost at renewal.
  • If you also have a cosmetic exclusion, see the cosmetic hail damage exclusion.

Depreciation and denial are different decisions

An old roof may be denied as worn out instead of paid with depreciation. That decision needs different evidence. See roof claims denied for wear and tear and wind damage roof claims.

Common questions

Will I get the depreciation back on my roof claim?

On a replacement cost policy, yes, after the roof is replaced and the notice deadline is met. With an actual cash value roof endorsement, no.

How do I know if my roof is covered at actual cash value?

Look in your forms list for an endorsement on actual cash value loss settlement for windstorm or hail losses to roof surfacing, or for a roof payment schedule.

How much do insurers depreciate a roof per year?

There is no standard rate. Insurers usually divide the roof's age by an expected life for the material, so check both numbers.

Can I dispute roof depreciation?

Yes. Provide the installation date, the shingle's rated life and evidence of condition. Disputes about the amount can go to appraisal.

Does depreciation apply to the interior damage?

Interior repairs may also carry depreciation on a replacement cost policy, recoverable after the work. An actual cash value roof endorsement does not change how the interior is settled.

What if I cannot afford to replace the roof before the depreciation is paid?

Tell the insurer and your contractor early. Some contractors schedule payment around the insurer's final check, and the insurer may confirm in writing what it will release on completion. Keep the 180-day notice deadline either way.

Help with roof depreciation

ClaimWarriors checks roof age, expected life and endorsements on hail and wind claims. The fee is free unless we win. Learn how we handle roof damage claims. Contact us for a claim review.

Examples are illustrative. This article is general information, not legal advice. Roof settlement terms vary by insurer; your policy controls. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050