Cosmetic Hail Damage Exclusion: What It Means for Your Roof and Siding

After a hailstorm, a metal roof can look like a golf ball and still keep water out. Insurers have written endorsements for exactly that case. A cosmetic hail damage exclusion removes coverage for wind or hail damage that only changes how a surface looks. If your policy has one, the claim turns on whether the damage affects how the roof or siding works.
Where the exclusion comes from
The base homeowners form (ISO HO-3) has no cosmetic exclusion. It is added by endorsement. ISO introduced two homeowners versions in 2016. HO 06 43, Cosmetic Damage Exclusion – Windstorm or Hail, applies to exterior surfacing such as roofs, siding, doors and windows. HO 06 44 applies to roof surfacing only and is used in fewer states. Many insurers write their own wording, and AAIS filed a similar endorsement in 2013.
Look for the endorsement in the list of forms on your declarations page. Some insurers give a premium credit for accepting it. See how to read a declarations page.
How "cosmetic" is defined
Definitions vary, which is why the exact wording matters. Common versions describe marring, pitting, dents or other superficial damage that changes the appearance of the surface without stopping it from working as a barrier. Some metal roof endorsements say the exclusion does not apply when hail damage lets water leak through the roof surface. A federal court applied that kind of wording in an Allstate case and found dents without leaks excluded.
Read three things in your endorsement:
- Which surfaces it applies to: the roof only, or siding, doors and windows too.
- Which materials: some apply only to metal roofs.
- What takes damage out of the exclusion: water penetration, a breach, a loss of function or a shorter life of the material.
A recent court decision
In October 2025, a federal court in Minnesota applied a cosmetic exclusion to hail-dented metal roofs on two school buildings (Cannon Falls Area Schools v. Hanover). The roofs had not leaked in the three years after the storm, and there were no punctures or open seams. The school's expert said the dents had used up part of the metal's capacity and made the panels more vulnerable to future storms. The court held that this did not change the result, because the exclusion asked whether the roof still worked as a barrier. An appeal has been reported. The case involved a commercial policy, and homeowners endorsements use similar wording.
Damage the exclusion usually does not reach
- Cracked, split or punctured shingles, panels or siding.
- Fractured shingles or exposed mat where hail broke through the surface.
- Loose or broken seams, fasteners or flashing.
- Water stains in the attic or rooms below that line up with the storm date.
- Damage to parts of the house the endorsement does not list, such as gutters or vents in some forms, or a roof made of a material the endorsement leaves out.
Interior damage from water that came in through an opening made by hail is handled under the normal policy terms.
How to build the evidence
- Have a roofer or engineer inspect for function: punctures, fractures, seam separation, fastener damage and moisture in the attic.
- Photograph damage with a scale, such as a coin or a tape measure.
- Ask for moisture readings where a leak is suspected.
- Keep a dated record of any leaks after the storm.
- Ask the insurer, in writing, which words of the endorsement it relies on and what inspection supports its view.
See what to expect at the adjuster's roof inspection.
Example: a dented metal roof and cracked siding
Illustrative numbers: a hailstorm dents a standing-seam metal roof and cracks vinyl siding on two walls. The policy has a cosmetic exclusion for metal roofs only. The insurer denies the roof, quoted at $32,000 to replace, and pays $3,400 for the siding less a $1,000 deductible, or $2,400. Six months later a seam opens at a dent and water stains a bedroom ceiling. A roofer's report ties the opening to the hail impact. Under the endorsement's own wording the roof now has functional damage, and the roof and ceiling can be raised with the insurer again. See reopening a closed claim.
Siding and matching
If hail cracked some siding and dented the rest, the insurer may pay for the cracked panels and call the dents cosmetic. If replacement panels do not match, matching rules in your state may still require a wider repair. See hail damage to siding and roof repair vs replacement.
Cosmetic exclusion and actual cash value roof coverage
Insurers use two different tools for older or hail-prone roofs. A cosmetic exclusion removes coverage for appearance-only damage. An actual cash value roof endorsement, such as ISO HO 04 93, keeps the coverage and pays the roof at depreciated value. A policy can have both. See roof depreciation in an insurance claim.
Before the next renewal
If you are offered a credit to accept a cosmetic exclusion, compare it with the cost of living with a dented roof you would have to pay to replace yourself. Homes with metal roofs in hail areas feel this exclusion the most.
Common questions
Does homeowners insurance cover cosmetic hail damage?
Under the standard form, yes, because dents are physical damage. If your policy has a cosmetic damage exclusion, appearance-only damage is not covered.
How do I know if my policy has a cosmetic exclusion?
Check the forms list on your declarations page for an endorsement with "cosmetic" in the title, or ask your agent for a complete copy of the policy.
Does the exclusion apply to my gutters?
Only if the endorsement lists them. Many cover roof surfacing, siding, doors and windows. Read the list of surfaces.
What if the dents start leaking later?
Report it in writing with photos and a roofer's opinion. Most cosmetic definitions stop applying once water gets through.
Can I dispute whether damage is cosmetic?
Yes. Get an independent inspection focused on function. Appraisal can settle the amount of loss, while whether damage is excluded is a coverage question the insurer has to explain in writing.
Help with a hail claim
ClaimWarriors reviews cosmetic exclusion denials and documents functional hail damage to roofs and siding. The fee is free unless we win. Learn how we handle hail damage claims. Contact us for a claim review.
Examples are illustrative. This article is general information, not legal advice. Endorsement wording varies by insurer; your policy controls. Last reviewed November 2026.







