How Much Does Insurance Pay for Hail Damage on a Roof?

Article made by:
ClaimWarriors
Close-up of dark metal roof tiles

How much does insurance pay for hail damage? Triple-I reports that the average homeowners wind and hail claim was about $15,708 from 2020 to 2024. Your payout is the cost to repair or replace everything the hail damaged, such as the roof, gutters, siding, screens and outdoor equipment, minus your deductible and any depreciation held back, and limited by how your policy settles roof losses. A separate percentage deductible for wind and hail, an actual cash value roof endorsement or a cosmetic damage exclusion can cut the check sharply.

This guide breaks down what a hail claim covers, the policy terms that change the number, and how to make sure nothing is left out.

What a hail claim can include

Hail can hit more than the roof. A complete hail claim can include:

  • Roof shingles or panels, plus underlayment, flashing, vents, pipe jacks and ridge cap.
  • Gutters and downspouts.
  • Siding, trim and fascia. See hail damage to siding.
  • Window screens, window frames and skylights.
  • Outdoor air conditioning units, whose fins can be crushed.
  • Fences, decks and sheds, under other structures coverage.
  • Interior water damage if hail opened the roof.

Cars aren't part of a homeowners claim. Hail damage to vehicles falls under the comprehensive coverage on your auto policy.

How the payout is calculated

  1. Start with the cost to repair or replace each damaged item.
  2. Subtract depreciation if the insurer pays actual cash value first.
  3. Subtract your deductible. In hail-prone states, that may be a separate wind and hail deductible.
  4. Apply any roof payment schedule, actual cash value roof endorsement or cosmetic exclusion.
  5. Add the withheld depreciation after repairs, if your policy pays replacement cost.

The standard ISO form, HO 00 03, pays no more than actual cash value until the repair or replacement is complete, and requires notice within 180 days after the loss that you intend to repair to keep replacement cost.

Policy terms that change the number

Percentage wind and hail deductibles

The Colorado Division of Insurance notes that many policies set the wind and hail deductible as a percentage of the dwelling coverage, such as 1%, 2% or 5%. On a $500,000 dwelling limit, 2% is $10,000.

Roof settlement endorsements

An actual cash value roof endorsement pays roof surfacing damaged by wind or hail at actual cash value only. A roof payment schedule pays a set percentage of replacement cost based on the roof's age and material. Both reduce what an older roof is paid. See how much insurance pays for a roof replacement.

Cosmetic damage exclusions

ISO's cosmetic damage endorsement excludes wind or hail damage that only changes the appearance of roofing, siding, doors or windows. Carrier versions may define cosmetic damage as dents or marring that don't let water in. These mostly affect metal roofs, metal siding and gutters. See cosmetic hail damage exclusions.

Depreciation

Older roofs carry heavy depreciation. Under a replacement cost policy, you get it back after the roof is replaced. Ask the insurer what age and life expectancy it used. See roof depreciation.

Example: one hailstorm, one house

A hailstorm damages a 10-year-old asphalt roof, the aluminum gutters, the vinyl siding on two sides, three window screens and the outdoor AC unit. The home is insured for $350,000 with a 1% wind and hail deductible of $3,500.

The estimate comes to $19,500 for the roof, $2,400 for gutters, $7,800 for siding, $300 for screens and $1,900 for the AC coil, for $31,900 in total. The insurer withholds $6,200 in depreciation. The first payments total $31,900 minus $6,200 minus $3,500, or $22,200. After repairs, the $6,200 is released, bringing the total to $28,400. These figures are illustrative.

If the same policy had an actual cash value roof endorsement and the roof depreciation was $5,000 of the $6,200, the total would stop at $23,400. If the siding couldn't be matched and the insurer priced only two sides, the claim might be short by the cost of the other sides.

Fences, sheds and outdoor equipment

Hail damage to a detached garage, shed or fence falls under other structures coverage, which the standard form sets at 10% of the dwelling limit unless you bought more. Fences are settled at actual cash value as structures that aren't buildings. The standard form doesn't cover trees, shrubs and plants for hail at all. For the outdoor air conditioning unit, insurers sometimes pay to straighten the fins instead of replacing the coil. If an HVAC technician says the coil can't be restored or efficiency has dropped, get that in writing.

Matching

Hail may damage only some slopes or some sides of the house. If new shingles or siding won't reasonably match what's left, some states' rules and some court decisions require insurers to go further. Discontinued siding is a typical example. See insurance matching laws.

How to get the full value

  1. Document every damaged item, not just the roof. Photograph soft metals, siding, screens and the AC unit.
  2. Get a roofer's and, if needed, a siding contractor's written estimate.
  3. Be present at the inspection and ask that every slope and elevation be inspected.
  4. Compare the insurer's estimate line by line, including code items and overhead and profit where several trades are needed.
  5. Send the 180-day notice of intent to repair and the final invoices to collect depreciation.
  6. Report hidden damage found during repairs as a supplement before it's covered up.

For the steps in order, see how to file a hail damage claim. If the insurer says the roof wasn't damaged, see hail damage claim denied.

Is a small hail claim worth filing?

With a percentage deductible, a small hail claim may pay little or nothing. Get estimates first and compare the total with your deductible. With a $5,000 deductible and a $6,500 estimate, for example, the claim would pay $1,500 before any depreciation is held back. These numbers are illustrative. Hail size matters too. See what size hail damages a roof.

Common questions

What is the average hail damage insurance payout?

Triple-I puts the average homeowners wind and hail claim at about $15,708 for 2020 to 2024. Hail claims that include a full roof and siding can be much higher.

Does insurance pay for a full roof replacement after hail?

If the damage is widespread or repair isn't possible, yes, subject to your deductible and any roof settlement endorsement.

Do I have to replace my roof to keep the insurance money?

Under a replacement cost policy, you keep the actual cash value payment, but you won't get the withheld depreciation unless you replace it. Your mortgage company may also be on the check.

Does insurance pay for gutters damaged by hail?

Yes, when hail dents or cracks them, unless a cosmetic damage exclusion in your policy applies to them. Dented gutters are also useful evidence that hail hit the roof.

Will a hail claim raise my premium?

It can. Some states limit increases after weather claims. Ask your agent how your insurer treats them.

Hail claim underpaid?

ClaimWarriors documents hail damage across the whole property and negotiates the difference. See our hail damage claim services or contact us for a free claim review.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Payouts depend on your policy and state law. Last reviewed November 2026.

Call Us 888-884-7050